If you drop Daddy's Girlfriend much lower, it gets the top 4 right. Though I might put Late Show Part 3 above Miami. (They're both terrific.) Putting aside Breaking Bad, Duckling was probably the best thing to air on television that year.
I find both Louie and Louis CK quite funny when I watch them, but find Louie in particular SO BLEAK that it's hard to watch.
Man, Miami and Late show...that's a tough choice there. I think I'd have to go with Late Show as well, primarily because I still think Lynch should have been nominated for it.