I DON'T REALLY NEED TO LOOK VERY MUCH FURTHER: Greatest American Idol Poll Ever: Which overused tune do you never want to hear again on ''Idol''?
It's amazing, but sad, how many songs have been performed 3+ times on the show. My vote, for what it's worth, went to Edwin McCain's ''I'll Be'' (performed by EJay Day, Joshua Gracin, and Bo Bice), because that song got retired once they did the montage of bad audition versions of the song (with McCain's commentary).
At this point, however, that song's finishing in the lead is against the odds, but it's the chance I've got to take . . .