My partner and I did it together and scored in the 98th percentile. We gave up with 2.27 to go because we didn't know Othello/Reversi.Fun!
I love you guys for the Portal reference alone
I think I'm disturbed that I got 35/36 - the only I didn't know was Pitfall.
34/36, but if I'd had my kids doing it with me I think we'd have gotten one and maybe both of the ones I just plain didn't know.
The original version I saw had 100 cupcakes, so it's even more insane than you imagined.
I got 35 of them, and the w knew the other one, so... woot.
I missed a couple of the cupcakes, but will take the opportunity to share a photo of the awesome Scrabble-themed cake that my girlfriend made me for my birthday last year:
I only got 31/36, and some of the ones I missed were stupid (I saw the Chutes & Ladders as a railroad bridge crossing a river). But I can offer you a picture of The Cupcakes of Catan:http://www.boardgamegeek.com/image/102475/the-settlers-of-catan(I had nothing to do with that besides finding the photo)
And yes, got both when we re-tried as a family version (wife got one, older kid got the other).
35/36 because I didn't know Centipede. And I knew I didn't know it, so I quit with 7:04 left.
We got 34. I knew Apples for Apples but could not think of the name to save my life. Scattergories was the other nemesis.