Friday, August 12, 2011

IT'S A TRUTH SO PURE IT CAN KILL YOU DEAD/A TASTE OF HEAVEN MIXED WITH HELL INSIDE OF MY HEAD: Am I right that there currently are only two half-hour dramas on television? Both Louie and Entourage have elements of comedy, but neither employs as many laugh lines as, say, The West Wing, and both usually, or at least frequently, are built principally around a dramatic (as opposed to comedic) plot. Louie sometimes does a purely sit-com plotline (smoking pot with a neighbor; going on a date with a masturbation opponent), and Entourage always has at least one gaggy secondary or tertiary plot, but at the core, the former is about a fundamentally lonely and discontent man and the latter is about an ambitious and self-destructive actor. The two are even superficially similar, centered around men (and masculinity) in the entertainment business almost entirely cut off from meaningful relationships with adult women.

But surprise. I'm not going to shit all over Entourage right now. I've said a million times that it is a puerile adolescent boy's fantasy, but Doug Ellin and company seem to be trying to grow the show up in this final season. Ellin seems to be tentatively testing the notion of attaching consequences to its characters' conduct, and I don't understand why more people aren't crediting the weirdly genius idea of using Andrew Dice Clay as shorthand for the failure and impending desperate obsolescence that the boys haven't yet had to deal with (excepting Drama's first couple of seasons). No, the show won't be complete until the moment we see a grown woman doing something other than shopping, ball-busting, or undressing, but one at least shouldn't criticize it for moving in the right direction.

All of which is a long way of saying that Entourage deserves slightly better than a comparison to its half-hour drama-mate, which, by doing whatever the hell Louis C.K. (and not network executives) wants, is reshaping the boundaries of broadcastable television. I suspect that FX paired up tonight's episodes because one (the one about God and masturbation) was kind of a clunker. But holy crap, that second episode, "Eddie," was one of the most brutal, clear-eyed, and sad things I've seen on television this year. It's as if Louis C.K. had read all of the first-season reviews about how Louie peeks into the aggression and unhappiness endemic among comedians and decided to kick the door wide open. Even the lone funny part (other than the bookend scenes of Louis C.K.'s stand-up), Eddie's bit at the open mic place, was grotesque, with the bad-comic montage, the yellowy lights, the drug sweat, and Eddie's offhand belligerence. Try to imagine watching this episode two years ago, or in, say, 1998 (when the debate was Friends or Seinfeld), or 1987. How alien would it have seemed?

8 comments:

  1. Ellin's CONSTANTLY seemed to toy with having Vinnie's bad behavior have consequences (the eternal struggle to make Medillin and its flopping, Vince gets fired from Smoke Jumpers, Vince spirals into coke addiction) but never seems to go anywhere--something always seems to pull him out of the fire at the last minute.

    ReplyDelete
  2. isaac_spaceman10:59 AM

    There were no consequences for Medellin -- Vinnie just kind of rolled with it; same with Smoke Jumpers.  Making him a self-destructive addict last season was a start, but I'm pretty confident that nothing in Vinnie Chase's life has sucked like taking a business meeting where he confronts a guy for whipsawing him and having the guy shoot himself.  The former is fantasy; the latter is a less abstract problem.   

    ReplyDelete
  3. Joseph J. Finn7:42 PM

    So wait, you're saying Two and a Half Men isn't an existential drama about the slow crushing despair of bachelorhood?  The hell you say.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I read the post bc I read Isaac religiously, but I don't watch either show so have nothing to say in the comments other than Go Isaac.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Deploying Doug Stanhope as Eddie in the long lost (emphasis on "lost") friend episode of Louie was pure electric awesome. 

    You can stream his No Refunds video on Netflix right now.  Right.  Now.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Adam C.11:06 AM

    Apparently because I lack control of phalangeal dexterity after three cups of coffee, I managed to delete my comment from last night.  Gist was, I was utterly blown away by the second Louie episode, but I wanted to dissent from Isaac's post only to say that I thought the first ep. of the night was pretty brilliant too (even if not in the same ballpark as "Eddie"). 

    And now I will go operate heavy machinery instead.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Stevie11:18 PM

    I wondered how much of the second episode of Louie was based on his conversation with Marc Maron on WTF. I mean, Marc Maron is obviously not the equivalent of Eddie, but the seeds are there.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Nigel from Cameroon11:43 AM

    This has to be the only post in the known universe that is about both Entourage and Louie. Together.

    ReplyDelete